Jump to content

The Framework of the Earth (Papers, 1921)

From thunderbay.wiki

"The Framework of the Earth" is a paper by Peter McKellar, F.G.S., in the 1921 annual of the Thunder Bay Historical Society. It was first given as his address to the society on 27 May 1921 and sets out his own theory of how the earth's crust, oceans, mountains and ice ages came to be.[1]

What it covers

McKellar says he is an amateur with no university training who has met eight geological problems that the standard works left unexplained: the folding of the Archean rocks, the formation of the oceans, their steep basins, collapses of the crust, mountain ranges, great plateaus, glacier phenomena and the shifting of the poles. He pictures a cooling earth whose first rain filled hollows that sank into the soft interior and crowded the lighter ground into land. He then proposes a "terrestrial truss" of strong ocean areas, weak land areas and rigid polar areas, in which the great weight of the oceans braces against the continents and pushes up the mountain ranges (the Himalayas against the Indian Ocean, for example). He backs this with tables of mountain and plateau heights.[1]

Turning to the ice age, he argues that glaciers formed where the crust was weak and so left the Pacific side of the continent largely clear. He cites local evidence from the north shore of Lake Superior: sedimentary rock inside Archean ground west of the Little Pic River, and the McKellar Pot-Holes, about fifty glacial potholes near Middleton station on the Canadian Pacific Railway, which his brother Donald McKellar found in 1875 and which McKellar reported on the following year in the Bulletin of the Geological Society of America. The paper closes with a supplement of quotations from F. A. Pouchet, Upham and other scientists on mountains, chalk and the ice age.[1]

Key Thunder Bay facts

  • McKellar signs himself F.G.S. and F.G.S.A.; he worked the same north shore country the paper draws on.[1]
  • The McKellar Pot-Holes lie about 1½ miles north of Middleton Station on the CPR, west of the Little Pic River.[1]
  • The paper takes up pp. 12–23 of the annual, with two diagram plates of the "terrestrial truss".[1]

References

  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 Peter McKellar, "The Framework of the Earth", Papers of the Thunder Bay Historical Society, 1921 (Thunder Bay Historical Society, Twelfth Annual Report), pp. 12–23 (scan pp. 16–27). archive.org.