Jump to content

Municipal boundaries of the Lakehead

From thunderbay.wiki


Municipal boundaries of the Lakehead
historical geography (overview)
AddressThunder Bay District, Ontario
Coordinates48.41167, -89.50223
View on map →

The municipal boundaries of the Lakehead are the present and former municipal and geographic-township limits around what is now the City of Thunder Bay and the rural municipalities immediately west, south and east of it. The map below shows the 2021 census-subdivision boundaries and the geographic townships of Oliver and Paipoonge, which together form the Municipality of Oliver Paipoonge.[1]

The coordinates in the infobox are those of the Ontario Heritage Foundation marker cairn at 4569 Oliver Road, Murillo, used here as an approximate centre for the rural townships west of the city.[2]

Oliver Paipoonge and neighbouring Lakehead municipalities, 2021 census-subdivision boundaries, with geographic township outlines. The dashed Oliver–Paipoonge line is a reconstruction of the pre-1998 municipal boundary from the geographic township layer.

What Oliver Paipoonge actually is

Oliver Paipoonge is not a neighbourhood of Thunder Bay and it is not the same thing as historic Oliver Township. It is a rural municipality of 350.51 square kilometres, with a 2021 population of 6,035 and a density of 17.2 people per square kilometre.[3] By comparison, the City of Thunder Bay (land area 327.77 km² in the 2021 CSD file) is a compact urban municipality immediately to the east.[4]

The present municipality is, for practical purposes, the two historic geographic townships of Oliver (surveyed in 1873 on the 640-acre section system, pattern 3) and Paipoonge (1,000-acre section system, the same class of survey as geographic Neebing).[5][1] Measured against the 2021 census-subdivision boundaries, more than 99 percent of each of those two geographic townships lies inside Oliver Paipoonge; only tiny slivers (on the order of one square kilometre in total) fall into neighbouring municipalities, likely boundary or shoreline differences rather than a documented annexation of a concession.[1]

The impression that the place is "just a long road with houses" comes from travelling the highway and concession-road corridors — notably Oliver Road and Highways 11/17, 61, 130, 588 and 590 — through a surveyed farm grid rather than through a downtown. The municipality has no single urban centre of the kind Fort William and Port Arthur had, but it does have distinct communities: Murillo (the historical seat of Oliver Township),[6] Rosslyn (the present municipal office, at 3250 Highway 130, on the Paipoonge side), the village of Kakabeka Falls beside the waterfall of that name, and smaller localities such as Stanley. The Slate River district is a farming settlement area in Paipoonge, described from the 1880s, not a single village point.[7] Hymers is in the Township of Gillies, not in Oliver Paipoonge.

The economy is still described by the municipality as primarily agricultural. A 2016 municipal economic plan, using the 2011 Census of Agriculture, said Oliver Paipoonge had 109 farms, just under half of all farms in the Thunder Bay District, and that most of those farms (55 percent) were in dairy or beef production, with other farms in hay, horses, vegetables, greenhouse and nursery production.[8] That farm role is older than the present bedroom-community commuting: the Ontario Heritage Foundation marker and the 1967 township marker present mid- and late-nineteenth-century Oliver as agricultural settlement supplying the Lakehead, and Hunt's 1924 paper describes farm settlement in the Slate River district of Paipoonge.[2][6][7] Kakabeka Falls Generating Station, on the Kaministiquia River just downstream of the falls, has generated electricity since 1906 (a four-unit station of about 25 MW, owned by Ontario Power Generation).[9] Thunder Bay International Airport is inside the City of Thunder Bay, on the west side of the built-up area (a point at about 48.372°N, 89.324°W falls in the 2021 Thunder Bay census subdivision, on land that is in the geographic township of Neebing). It is not in Oliver Paipoonge.

How the boundaries changed

Nineteenth-century townships

Shuniah was organised in 1873 and originally included several geographic townships around the Lakehead, among them McIntyre, McGregor, Neebing and Paipoonge.[10] The Municipality of Neebing, incorporated in March 1881 (44 Victoria, c. 43), was originally composed of the townships of Blake, Crooks, Pardee, Paipoonge, Neebing, and Neebing Additional (the late township of Fort William, also known as McKellar Ward), with adjoining islands, each constituting one ward.[11] In 1892 Neebing Additional, and part of the geographic township of Neebing, withdrew; that is the municipal beginning of the City of Fort William as a separate urban municipality.[11][12] The Municipality of Neebing today states that some acreage was lost through annexation to Fort William in 1892.[12] Paipoonge withdrew from the Municipality of Neebing in 1904 and became a township municipality in its own right.[11]

Oliver Township was never part of that Neebing municipality. It was surveyed in 1873 and organised its own township government after elections on 30 December 1878, conventionally dated as incorporated in 1879, so that local roads could be built for farm lots.[2][6]

Port Arthur and Fort William both became cities in April 1907.[13]

The 1970 city

On 26 October 1964, Saul Laskin, mayor of Port Arthur, asked the province for a study of local government among five municipalities: Port Arthur, Fort William, Neebing, Paipoonge and Shuniah. The heads of those five councils jointly requested the study in 1965, and Eric Hardy was appointed that September to conduct the Lakehead Local Government Review.[13] Oliver Township is not named in that five-municipality list.

On 16 April 1968 the minister of municipal affairs, Darcy McKeough, outlined Hardy's main recommendation: that Fort William and Port Arthur, and adjacent territories from the municipalities of Shuniah and Neebing, be joined to form a single city.[14] The province accepted the report's recommendations and passed a provincial bill on 8 May 1969 (originally the City of The Lakehead Act, 1968–69). The City of Thunder Bay came into being on 1 January 1970, consisting of Fort William, Port Arthur, and the adjacent geographic townships of Neebing and McIntyre.[13]

Those two geographic townships now lie almost entirely inside the City of Thunder Bay (about 99.7 percent of geographic Neebing and 99.8 percent of McIntyre, measured against the 2021 CSD boundaries).[1] The present Municipality of Neebing is not the same as that geographic township: after 1970 it kept the name but was left with Blake, Crooks and Pardee, and in 1999 it gained the former unincorporated townships of Pearson and Scoble.[12][11] Shuniah continued as a municipality, today mainly the geographic townships of MacGregor and McTavish, east of the city. A small part of MacGregor (about 6.5 km², or 2 percent of that township) falls inside the present city boundary.[1]

Oliver and Paipoonge were not taken into the 1970 city. Their geographic townships remain outside Thunder Bay as the Municipality of Oliver Paipoonge.

The 1998 amalgamation

The 1996 Standard Geographical Classification still listed Oliver (CSD 3558024) and Paipoonge (CSD 3558008) as separate census subdivisions.[15] On 1 January 1998 they were amalgamated to form the Municipality of Oliver Paipoonge.[16] Statistics Canada reports the 1996 population of that new geography, with an adjustment flag, as 5,907, and the 2001 population as 5,862.[17] The 2021 population was 6,035.[3] Official separate 1996 counts for each old township were not taken from a Statistics Canada table in this pass (only the combined, adjusted figure). The 1998 merger was part of the Ontario municipal restructuring of the late 1990s, during the premiership of Mike Harris; Schweitzer writes that the provincial government amalgamated the two townships.[16] The original restructuring order or Ontario Gazette text was not located in this pass. The two townships were joined to each other, not annexed to Thunder Bay.

Why a separate municipality?

The short answer is that Oliver and Paipoonge were created, and later left outside the city, as rural farm townships, not as a tax suburb of Fort William.

Township municipalities were the ordinary Ontario unit for a surveyed agricultural grid under the municipal law of the late nineteenth century. Oliver's 1878 organising movement, on the Ontario Heritage Foundation marker, was about getting roads built for settlers on free-grant lots.[2] Paipoonge's farm settlement, as Hunt described it in 1924, was of the same kind.[7] For a time (1881–1904) Paipoonge was a ward of the rural Municipality of Neebing; it left that municipality in 1904, after the urban port lands had already gone into Fort William in 1892.[11] So Paipoonge was not "kept out" of Fort William after the fact: the city was carved out of the urban part of a larger rural municipality, and Paipoonge later stood on its own.

In the 1960s the question was raised again, and formally. Paipoonge was one of the five municipalities in the Hardy review.[13] Hardy's published headline recommendation, as restated by the minister in April 1968, was to join the two cities plus adjacent territories from Neebing and Shuniah — that is, the suburban fringe wrapping the built-up area — not the whole rural belt.[14] What the 1970 city actually received were the geographic townships of Neebing and McIntyre, which today make up a large share of the city's land: McIntyre on the north and west of the old Port Arthur side, and geographic Neebing on the south and west of the old Fort William side, immediately east of Paipoonge (the Westfort and airport side of the present city).[13][1] Oliver and Paipoonge stayed outside.

Whether lower taxes were a reason some residents preferred to stay out is a fair question, but it is not a finding supported by the sources consulted here. No tax-rate comparison, no petition framed as tax avoidance, and no passage of the Hardy report itself (the 1968 printed report was not obtained in this pass) has been cited to show that Oliver or Paipoonge existed, or were left out in 1970, "just so as not to pay Fort William taxes." Analysis: a rural township does typically levy for a different, lighter set of urban services than a city (no city-wide transit, a different water and sewer pattern, rural road standards), so living outside the city has always had a fiscal consequence. That is not the same as saying the townships were invented, or preserved, as a tax shelter. Their first purpose in the sources is agricultural settlement and local roads; their later purpose, still stated by the municipality, is a farm and rural-residential community next to the city, with Kakabeka Falls as a major landscape and hydroelectric site.[8][9] The 1998 restructuring merged the two rural townships with each other rather than folding them into Thunder Bay.[16]

See also

References

  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 "Geographic Township Improved", Geospatial Ontario (King's Printer for Ontario). The layer attributes give Oliver as "640 AC. SEC. PAT. 3" and Paipoonge and Neebing as "1000 AC. SEC." Overlaps with 2021 census-subdivision boundaries were measured from this layer and the Statistics Canada 2021 digital CSD boundary file (CSDUID 3558*). The map derived from these files is at File:Oliver Paipoonge and Lakehead municipalities map.png.
  2. ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 "The Founding of Oliver Township", The Historical Marker Database (inscription of the Ontario Heritage Foundation marker at the Oliver Paipoonge Municipal Centre, Murillo). Archived.
  3. ↑ 3.0 3.1 "Census Profile, 2021 Census of Population – Oliver Paipoonge, Municipality (MU)", Statistics Canada.
  4. ↑ "2021 Census Boundary files", Statistics Canada; land area of Oliver Paipoonge 350.51 km² is from the 2021 Census Profile. Digital boundary files include water and should not be used as legal surveys.
  5. ↑ "List of Subdivided Townships in the Province of Ontario with Dates and Systems of Survey" (Association of Ontario Land Surveyors, February 1997). Archived.
  6. ↑ 6.0 6.1 6.2 Township of Oliver centennial marker (1967), The Historical Marker Database. Archived.
  7. ↑ 7.0 7.1 7.2 J. M. Hunt, "Pioneers of Paipoonge", Papers of the Thunder Bay Historical Society, 1924, pp. 23–24. archive.org. Archived.
  8. ↑ 8.0 8.1 "Municipality of Oliver Paipoonge: Strategic Economic Development Plan 2016–2020" (30 September 2016), citing Statistics Canada, Census of Agriculture, 2011 (CANSIM table 004-0200). Archived.
  9. ↑ 9.0 9.1 "Redeveloping Kakabeka Falls Generating Station", Ontario Power Generation. Archived.
  10. ↑ M. J. L. Black, "Place Names in the Vicinity of Fort William", Thunder Bay Historical Society, Sixteenth and Seventeenth Annual Reports (1926). Archived.
  11. ↑ 11.0 11.1 11.2 11.3 11.4 "G 8 Municipality of Neebing Fonds" (finding aid), Thunder Bay Museum. Archived.
  12. ↑ 12.0 12.1 12.2 "History", Municipality of Neebing. Archived.
  13. ↑ 13.0 13.1 13.2 13.3 13.4 "History of Amalgamation", City of Thunder Bay. Archived.
  14. ↑ 14.0 14.1 "Amalgamation: Uniting Two Systems 1970s-1990s", City of Thunder Bay (125 Years of Transit exhibit). Archived.
  15. ↑ "Standard Geographical Classification (SGC) 1996 – 3558 Thunder Bay District", Statistics Canada. The 1 January 1996 classification lists Paipoonge (CSD 3558008) and Oliver (CSD 3558024) as separate census subdivisions. Archived.
  16. ↑ 16.0 16.1 16.2 Marg Schweitzer, "What's in a Name? Notes from the past", The Oliver Paipoonge News, vol. 30, no. 3 (March 2026). Archived.
  17. ↑ "Population and Dwelling Counts, for Canada, Census Metropolitan Areas, Census Agglomerations and Census Subdivisions (Municipalities), 2001 and 1996 Censuses – 100% Data", Statistics Canada, Thunder Bay CMA table.